Welcome to Miller Pizza
Miller Pizza, located in Michigan City, IN, is a haven for pizza enthusiasts. Renowned for its authentic Chicago-style pizzas, each 16" pie weighs between 7-8 pounds, making it perfect for sharing. The house-made sauce, coupled with creamy Alfredo and fresh pesto options, sets Miller apart from traditional pizzerias. The friendly staff enhances the dining experience, creating a welcoming atmosphere for all. Diners rave about the crispy fried pickles and mouthwatering appetizers, which complement the pizza offerings. With reasonable prices and generous portions, Miller Pizza is ideal for families seeking delicious, hearty meals. A must-visit for true pizza lovers!
-
1012 N Karwick Rd, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States1012 N Karwick Rd, Michigan City, IN 46360, United States Hotline: +1 219-878-9480
Welcome to Miller Pizza, located at 1012 N Karwick Rd, Michigan City, Indiana. This charming pizzeria has established itself as a must-visit destination for pizza enthusiasts, especially those who adore the iconic Chicago-style pizza. With a phone number of +1 219-878-9480, you can easily reach out to place your orders in advance, which is highly recommended given the tantalizing culinary creations awaiting you.
Miller Pizza is renowned for its unique and delectable pizza sauce, a closely guarded recipe that customers rave about. One enthusiastic patron, David Valderrama, shared how he was first drawn in by a four-star review, only to return and upgrade it to five stars after savoring what he calls “the real deal” — a Chicago-style pie that’s both generous in size and flavor. Each 16-inch pizza weighs a hefty 7-8 pounds, making it a perfect option for gatherings, easily feeding 5 to 6 hungry diners.
But it’s not just the pizza that makes Miller stand out. The staff’s commitment to customer service shines through in reviews from visitors like Jeff Rubleski, who appreciated their warm demeanor and careful attention to detail when ordering. The stuffed pizzas, laden with cheese and flavor, have a way of turning first-time eaters into lifelong fans, as highlighted by patrons like Chhoeun Dalton. For him, discovering the Chicago-style pizza here was a transformative experience that redefined his understanding of this classic dish.
Another delightful feature of Miller Pizza is the addition of intriguing sauces, including house-made Alfredo, pesto, and olive oil, allowing diners to personalize their meals to their tastes. Fried pickles and creamy chicken Alfredo also add a layer of culinary satisfaction and comfort, making your visit smooth and enjoyable. Michelle, who celebrated her anniversary there, couldn’t help but express her obsession with the fried pickles, a delightful appetizer that is a perfect companion to their main offerings.
Miller Pizza is not just a restaurant; it’s a gathering place filled with warmth, tasty food, and friendly faces. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick bite or ordering ahead for a family feast, you’ll savor the experience as much as the pizza itself. So, next time you find yourself in Michigan City, be sure to visit Miller Pizza — where tradition meets flavor in every slice!
I originally gave this store four stars but I have changed it to a five. I have been to this place twice since this review and I must say that their Chicago style pizza is my favorite! Also, the workers were more friendly these last times. The owner is a really nice guy. There pizza sauce is their own recipe and is far better than any other sauce I have tasted at a pizza restaurant. They also offer a house Alfredo sauce, pesto and an olive oil. Each 16"pie weighs about 7-8 pounds! Be sure to order ahead because to cook the pizza it takes about one hour. A 16" large with a few toppings cost about 28, very reasonable. After one or two pieces you are full, so one 16" pizza will feed about 5-6 people. This is the real deal. Real pizza. Very glad to find it.
Took my daughter here on the way back from Chicago back home to Michigan. Called ahead to order and the staff was incredibly friendly both on the phone and also in person. I felt they went above and beyond to answer some of my questions beforehand and were awesome once we got there! Most importantly the stuffed pizza was absolutely perfect. We brought home an extra pizza and our kids ate it over holiday leftovers!
This is the first place I had a "Chicago style" pizza pie. And it changed my entire perspective on pizza. Best pizza I ever had. But you have to have it fresh. It has sooo much cheese. Don't let it get cold.
Hubby and I came up to Michigan to celebrate our anniversary and passed this by otw to our hotel. We thought to try this place after we got our room situated and I'm glad we did. Very nice staff (lovely girl had served us) and delicious pizza. Got totally hooked on the fried pickles! We had grabbed another pizza otw way back home!
We had a delivery nearby and was told that this place has the best food My husband got the Chicago stuffed pizza with chicken and Alfredo sauce.. Absolutely delicious And I got the chicken Alfredo which was super yummy I love the thicker type Alfredo sauce and the noodles plus the amount of chicken in it was so perfect and I was in heaven with their food
Italian beef pizza half hot, half mild pepper was amazing!!!
We had Miller's Pizza for the first time. And I would differently go back if we was closer. We had a thin crust pizza half and half, wings and fried green tomatoes!!! It was all very good!!! I would recommend everyone to try it out.( Picture does not do it justice.)
Great food as always!!! Mike n Mary kill it!!! Miller's is are go to lunch spot for the 2 slice special. Don't miss out.